Government intervention via taxes are not the answer to fixing Canadaâ€™s heated housing market
RE/MAX Canada Media Statement: Government intervention via taxes are not the answer to fixing
Canadaâ€™s heated housing market
Toronto, ON and Kelowna, BC, April 6, 2021 â€“ Long-term industry-wide changes to improving housing
affordability and making the market more transparent, such as increasing our national housing supply,
making all purchases conditional on financing to reduce financial overextension of buyers, and
regulations concerning listing price thresholds, might be the answer to cooling the exuberance
enveloping Canadaâ€™s housing market. Defaulting to conventional changes in tax and/or mortgage
policies, as has been deployed unsuccessfully in the recent past, are not recipes for success, as they do
not address the root causes.
Yes, Canada, we have a housing problem with the unprecedented levels of activity â”€ from soaring price
increases across virtually all markets spurred-on by overwhelming demand to profound challenges in
housing affordability. While COVID-19 has made this significantly more pronounced, the issues facing
Canadaâ€™s housing market were brewing long before the pandemic struck.
There have been many unintended consequences of previous government interventions that have, in
fact, exacerbated our current predicament. In many ways, Canadian real estate is still reeling from the
pent-up housing demand of 2017, when cooling measures such as the foreign buyerâ€™s tax and the
mortgage stress test pushed many homebuyers to the sidelines. People bided their time and, in many
instances, saved their money with the aim of getting back in at a later date.
That time hit with a bang as a result of COVID-19. The countryâ€™s collective self-reflection of all things
quality of life related, coupled with record household savings and the abundance of â€˜cheap moneyâ€™
created the problem we have today.
The data does show that the cooling measures leveraged by the federal government in 2017 (confirm
date) certainly offered short-term relief. But these measures failed to address the core problem of
supply, particularly supply of affordable housing in Canadaâ€™s larger metropolitan markets. Without
helping cultivate a much healthier balance between supply and demand, all other interventions by the
government will be mere band-aid remedies.
The question then becomes, how can we cool this overheated market, if not through policy or
taxation? Here are a few options:
- Add more housing supply. This is the most critical solution to our housing crisis. We need to incentivize more development of affordable, family-sized housing like three-bedroom condos, and allow for more detached housing beyond our existing urban centres. Realistically, we canâ€™t continue to fight urban sprawl while simultaneously expecting housing prices to cool. Itâ€™s not feasible. What weâ€™re seeing in the market right now is simple economics â€“ low supply and high demand. We need more homes to meet Canadiansâ€™ current needs, while anticipating the housing needs of the 1.2 million people who are expected to immigrate to Canada through 2023. Maybe now is the time to consider expanding the boundaries of developable land.
- Add a mandatory condition to every offer, making the purchase conditional on receiving financial or legal approval on the purchase. In multiple offer situations, this would reduce buyerâ€™s remorse and would help to ensure that people can afford what they are buying.
- Provincial regulators need to get more involved. For example, review transactions where homes are sold well over asking price. This would ensure fair listing prices, and prevent homes being listed well below market value to create bidding wars. Agents who are found to be contravening these rules would be forced to face fines.
Elton Ash, Regional Executive Vice President, RE/MAX of Western Canada
Christopher Alexander, Chief Strategy Officer and Executive Vice President, RE/MAX of Ontario-Atlantic